Who this is for
- Canadian residents asked by the CRA to explain large deposits, transfers from abroad or a home purchase
- Newcomers who brought savings earned before they became residents
- People who received a gift, a loan or an inheritance from family abroad
- Households facing a CRA net worth audit
Not covered here
- Whether a gift or an inheritance from abroad is taxed or reported
- Business deposits, mixed accounts and bookkeeping
- Objections, appeals and the steps of a voluntary disclosure
- Another country's exchange-control rules, and criminal investigations
- Revenu Québec's own audits of Quebec returns
CRA asking where your money came from: do bank deposits count as income?
A bank deposit is not income just because it is large. The CRA counts gifts and inheritances as non-taxable sources, and money earned abroad before you lived in Canada is not taxed here. But when the CRA asks, it expects you to show where each amount came from, with documents. The CRA's audit manual tells auditors that a deposit stays non-taxable unless the evidence shows it is more likely than not that it came from a taxable source.
A case stops being simple when:
- the money moved through another person's account, or in cash;
- the papers were written later, not when the money moved;
- a foreign property form (T1135) was due and never filed;
- the amounts are large beside the income on your returns;
- an earlier answer, such as a return, a mortgage application or a gift letter, says something different.
Your first written answer matters: auditors are told to test what you say against other evidence, so a reply that contradicts your returns, mortgage file or an earlier gift letter weakens everything after it. Before replying, gather the CRA letter, bank statements for every year it asks about, the home purchase file, the transfer records, and the giver's or the estate's papers.
Why is the CRA asking how I paid for my home? The CRA lifestyle audit
The CRA compares the income on your returns with what your life costs. It says it considers whether reported income is enough to support a taxpayer's lifestyle, including the cost and upkeep of real estate, and that buying an expensive asset such as a high-end home with no obvious income source can point to unreported income. Residents of Canada must report worldwide income, so money arriving from abroad raises the question of whether it was income.
Transfers from abroad are visible to the CRA. Banks and other reporting entities must report to it each international electronic funds transfer of $10,000 or more, and the CRA says it uses that data to assess offshore risk.
A question is not a finding. The letter you received lists what the auditor wants and by when; answer that list, not a generic one.
Can the CRA see my bank account, in Canada and abroad?
Yes, by several routes. It can ask you, ask your bank, read transfer reports and receive account data from other countries.
| Route | What the law or the CRA says |
|---|---|
| Your own records | An auditor may examine your documents and require you to answer proper questions, in writing if asked (s. 231.1). |
| Banks and other third parties in Canada | The CRA may send a notice requiring any person to provide information or documents within a reasonable time (s. 231.2). |
| Transfers across the border | Each international electronic transfer of $10,000 or more is reported (s. 244.2). |
| Accounts in other countries | Tax administrations that have adopted the Common Reporting Standard exchange financial account information automatically each year (CRA). |
| Records kept abroad | The CRA may require a resident of Canada to provide information or documents located outside Canada, with at least 90 days to produce them (s. 231.6). |
A requirement for foreign records has teeth. You may ask a judge to review it within 90 days after the notice is sent or served, but it is not unreasonable merely because a related non-resident you do not control, such as a parent, holds the records. If you do not substantially comply, a court must, if the CRA asks, stop you from later using the records the notice covered in a civil case, such as a tax appeal (s. 231.6(8)).
What is a CRA net worth audit, and how is the number built?
A net worth audit rebuilds your income from what your household owns, owes and spends, instead of from your return. The Minister is not bound by a return and may assess on other evidence. The CRA calls net worth its most common method of indirect verification of income.
Section 13.4 of the audit manual sets out the method:
| Step | What goes in |
|---|---|
| 1. Net worth at the start and at the end | Everything the household owns, business and personal, at cost, less everything it owes. |
| 2. Increase in net worth | The end figure minus the start figure. |
| 3. Add personal spending | What the household spent to live during the period, plus losses you cannot deduct. |
| 4. Subtract non-taxable sources | Gifts, inheritances, lottery winnings and other receipts that are not income, as far as they are shown. |
| 5. Compare | The result against the total income reported by every contributing member of the household. |
Any amount left over is treated as unreported income. Three details matter:
- Cost, not value. Assets are counted at what they cost, not at what they are worth today. A loan still owed counts as a debt in step 1.
- The household. The unit ordinarily includes you, your spouse or common-law partner and minor dependent children living with you. Other adults in the home, such as parents or grown children, can be added where assets, debts or spending are mixed.
- Estimated spending. Where there are no records of an expense, auditors may estimate it, with Statistics Canada's average household spending as a guide to what is reasonable. The manual says the benefit of the doubt on an estimate must favour you, so check each one against your actual costs.
In the formula, each non-taxable source that is shown is subtracted in full.
How do I prove money was a gift, a loan or an inheritance from abroad?
Answer the questions the auditor is told to ask: who paid, when, in what form, where the money went, and whether it must be repaid. The audit manual (sections 13.2.6 and 13.2.8) also tells auditors to request supporting documents, to confirm with the payer or the executor where there is doubt, and to check whether the payer had the funds or the income to pay that amount.
| What the money was | Documents that answer those questions |
|---|---|
| Gift | The giver's signed statement (name, address, relationship, amount, date, no repayment); the giver's bank record of the money leaving; your record of it arriving; evidence the giver could afford it, such as savings, a property sale or income. |
| Loan | The agreement or note made when the money moved; the lender's record of the money leaving and yours of it arriving; the repayment terms and any repayments made; evidence of the lender's means. |
| Inheritance | The will; the executor's or the estate's statement of what you received; the record of the transfer from the estate to you. |
The manual says an audit of an inheritance is ordinarily limited to the executed will and the documents supporting the transfer. For cash, auditors ask the currency, the denominations and the details of any exchange. If you carried $10,000 or more in cash into Canada, you had to report it to the CBSA at the border; any record of that report, with the deposit slip for when the cash went in, is evidence made at the time.
The giver's means matter as much as the transfer. If the evidence shows the payer had neither the funds nor the income to support the amount, auditors are told not to count it as one of your resources. The manual says a payer who is not a resident of Canada has no obligation under the Income Tax Act to give the CRA information, so bringing the giver's papers falls to you.
Whether the gift itself is taxed or reported is in gifts from family abroad; an inheritance, in inheriting from abroad.
I brought savings from before I immigrated: are they taxable, and how do I show them?
Money you earned outside Canada before you became a resident is not taxed in Canada, the CRA says. What those savings earn after you become a resident, such as interest, rent or gains, is part of the worldwide income a resident reports.
Property you still owned abroad when you arrived, such as a home or shares, is treated as bought at its value on that day (s. 128.1). If you sold it later, only that value is savings from before; a gain since then is income to report. See selling property abroad: arrival value and foreign tax before you reply.
Show what you held on the day you became a resident. A net worth calculation starts from opening balances, so savings that are not in the opening figure look like income earned later. Gather:
- statements for each account, in Canada and abroad, around your arrival date;
- sale contracts and proof of proceeds for property or a business sold abroad and, for a sale after you arrived, its value on your arrival date;
- later transfers into Canada that match, in amount and date, money leaving those accounts.
Savings left abroad can also trigger the foreign property form when their total cost is more than $100,000 (s. 233.3), though not for the year you first became a resident (s. 233.7). If that form was missed, read a missed foreign property report before you reply, because your answer and the form must agree.
The money came through relatives' accounts, a friend or a money changer: how do I trace it?
Trace the money hop by hop. For each step, get the sender's record of the money leaving, the receiver's record of it arriving, and a signed statement from each person in the chain. Amounts and dates should line up after exchange rates and fees.
With a money changer, the deposit in Canada often comes from a stranger, and one side has no bank record; the manual notes that small exchanges through a broker may leave none. Gather your family's record of paying the changer, any receipt or message showing the amount and rate, and your statement showing the deposit, then explain the gap in writing.
The audit manual lists the auditor's own steps for foreign funds: asking for third-party confirmation from abroad by phone or letter, using a bank authorization you sign to get transfer details, and asking the foreign tax agency. Gaps in the chain are yours to fill.
Never create or backdate a document. A statement written today carries today's date and says what the writer remembers. A false answer to the CRA can draw the false-statement penalty (s. 163) and can be an offence (s. 239).
The manual notes that many countries have currency controls. Whether a transfer route met another country's rules is not a Canadian tax question and needs advice in that country.
What if I cannot prove a deposit?
An unproven deposit is not automatically income, but it is exposed. The audit manual says a deposit remains non-taxable and cannot be assessed unless the evidence shows a taxable source is more likely than not, and that real doubt is decided in the taxpayer's favour. Where the payer has died or cannot be found, auditors are told to rely on the credibility of the statements.
Three limits apply:
- The manual guides auditors. It is not a guarantee to taxpayers.
- The same manual says that if a taxpayer does not comply with an auditor's requirement under s. 231.1(1) for documents on foreign funds, the auditor should consider assessing the amount as taxable income from a foreign source.
- In a net worth calculation, a source that is not shown is not subtracted, so it stays in the gap.
Explain in writing what is missing and why; the CRA asks for a written explanation when documents are not available. Send what does exist: partial records, other people's statements, and anything made at the time.
Will the CRA ask for my spouse's or family's records?
Yes, where the net worth method is used. The CRA's audit page, written for business owners, says it needs a complete financial picture of the family unit and will ask for the personal financial records of a spouse and of any other contributing member of the household.
Relatives abroad who gave or lent the money may be asked to confirm it; an unconfirmed gift is weaker evidence.
How far back can the CRA go?
Normally three years from the day the CRA sent the first notice of assessment for the year. Section 152 of the Income Tax Act opens older years in these cases:
| Situation | Time limit |
|---|---|
| Ordinary case | three years after the first notice of assessment |
| A misrepresentation from neglect, carelessness or wilful default, or fraud | None, for what the misrepresentation affects |
| A T1135 was not filed on time, or left a property out, and income from a foreign property the form covers was not reported | three years beyond the normal period, for the whole year |
| The reassessment results from a transaction with a non-resident you do not deal with at arm's length, such as a parent abroad | three years beyond the normal period, for what relates to that transaction |
| You sold real estate, in Canada or abroad, and left the sale off that year's return | No limit for that sale; once you report it on an amended return, three years from then |
| You signed a waiver within the normal period | Open for what the waiver covers |
The audit manual says a net worth audit ordinarily covers the latest filed year and the year before, plus the opening balances. It lets auditors expand to years past the normal reassessment period where carelessness, neglect or possible fraudulent misrepresentation is clearly indicated; going beyond three years needs a team leader's approval.
What is at stake, and who has to prove what?
The stake is tax on the gap, interest, and often a penalty. A false statement or omission made knowingly, or in circumstances amounting to gross negligence, carries a penalty of the greater of $100 and 50% of the understated tax (s. 163). Where that penalty does not apply but $500 or more went unreported in a year and in any of the three years before, a penalty of up to 10% of the unreported amount can apply (s. 163(1)). The audit manual tells auditors to consider this penalty in every net worth assessment of underreported income, and calls not applying it the exception.
The assessment is deemed valid and binding unless changed on objection or appeal, or by a reassessment. For the penalty, the reverse holds: on appeal, the CRA must establish the facts that justify it (s. 163(3)).
Relief from penalties and interest is in penalties, interest and relief. If the questions turn to suspected tax evasion or a criminal investigation, speak to a tax lawyer before any interview.
What should my reply to the CRA look like?
One schedule with numbered documents behind it, sent by the date in the letter.
- Read the letter for the years, the accounts, the items, the reply date and the reference number.
- Build one schedule with a row for each deposit or payment: date, amount, account, source and document number.
- Attach the documents, numbered to match the schedule.
- Check every line against your returns, your T1135s, the mortgage application and any gift letter given to a lender.
- Reply within the time in the letter and quote its reference number. You or an authorized representative may send scanned documents online through your CRA account, the CRA says.
- If documents are missing, add a written explanation. If you need more time, call the number in the letter before the date passes.
If the auditor proposes a net worth assessment, you receive the statement of changes in net worth and its spending worksheets, and have 30 days to respond. Check each line: the opening balances, the spending estimates, and the sources that were not subtracted.
Reviews versus audits, extensions, representation and objections are in CRA reviews, audits and voluntary disclosure.
Example
These examples are illustrative; all figures are in Canadian dollars.
A down payment from a gift and savings from before arrival
A couple from Karachi report C$45,000 a year and buy a C$1,400,000 home in Mississauga with C$500,000 down. The CRA asks how they paid.
- C$300,000 was a gift wired by the husband's father. They send his signed statement, his bank statement showing the wire leaving and the savings behind it, their statement showing it arriving, and the gift letter given to the lender, which shows the same amount and no repayment.
- C$200,000 was their own savings from before arrival. They send the account balances on their arrival date and two transfers, C$120,000 and C$80,000, that match money leaving those accounts. Because the savings stayed abroad after they arrived, they also check whether a T1135 was due for any later year before sending the schedule.
Their schedule accounts for the full C$500,000, one document set per line. It does not end the question: the CRA also weighs the cost of carrying the home, so they show who pays the C$900,000 mortgage on C$45,000 of income, with the same kind of proof for any ongoing help, and check that the income on the mortgage application matches their returns.
A net worth traced over three years
A household in Burnaby reports C$40,000 a year. Its net worth rises from C$200,000 to C$650,000 over three years, and it spends C$50,000 a year.
| Year | Increase in net worth | Spending | Reported income | Gap | Non-taxable source proved | Left over |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | C$20,000 | C$50,000 | C$40,000 | C$30,000 | None | C$30,000 |
| 2 | C$340,000 | C$50,000 | C$40,000 | C$350,000 | C$350,000 inheritance from Seoul, shown by the estate statement | C$0 |
| 3 | C$90,000 | C$50,000 | C$40,000 | C$100,000 | C$100,000 gift from a sister, shown by her bank record | C$0 |
| Total | C$450,000 | C$150,000 | C$120,000 | C$480,000 | C$450,000 | C$30,000 |
The starting gap is C$480,000. The two proved sources cut it to C$30,000, in year 1, which is what is left to explain or be assessed.
Money that came through a cousin's account
A man in Toronto received C$90,000 from his family in Lahore in three transfers of C$30,000, each through a cousin's account in Dubai. He lines up, for each transfer, the family's record of paying the cousin, the cousin's statement showing the money arriving and leaving, and his own statement showing it arriving. His family and the cousin each sign a note, dated the day it is written, saying what was sent and why. Small differences from exchange rates and fees are explained on the schedule.
Different for you?
- The letter has a reply date and the amounts are large: the first written answer is tested against your returns, T1135s and mortgage file, so it must match them. Have it checked first with cross-border tax help.
- The proof shows foreign income that was never reported: the voluntary disclosure program is closed for an issue already under audit, and a letter naming the omission makes an application prompted, with less relief (unreported income and voluntary disclosure). Get cross-border tax help before you answer.
- A spouse working abroad pays for the household: see family stays in Canada while you work abroad and get cross-border tax help.
- A foreign property form was never filed: see a missed foreign property report for assets back home.
- Parents abroad paid for a home in your name: see a home in your name paid for by parents abroad.
- The deposits went through a business or a mixed account: see what triggers a CRA audit; for parents' money put into a business, see money from parents abroad in your business.
- The CRA is questioning a foreign tax credit or your residency instead: see a foreign tax credit review or the CRA residency questionnaire.
- The CRA suspects tax evasion or has opened a criminal investigation: that is work for a tax lawyer, before any interview.
Figures on this page
| Figure | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| FINTRAC international electronic funds transfer report threshold Financial entities report an international electronic funds transfer they initiate or finally receive of this amount or more in a single transaction, in Canadian dollars; the 24-hour rule aggregates smaller transfers | $10,000 | FINTRAC: Reporting electronic funds transfers Checked |
| Minimum time to produce records under a CRA requirement for foreign-based information The notice must set a reasonable period of not less than this for producing information or documents located outside Canada | 90 days | Income Tax Act, s. 231.6(3) Checked |
| Time to apply to a judge to review a CRA requirement for foreign-based information Counted from the day the notice is sent or served | 90 days | Income Tax Act, s. 231.6(4) Checked |
| CBSA reporting threshold for currency and monetary instruments carried into or out of Canada Currency or monetary instruments valued at CAN$10,000 or more must be reported to the CBSA when entering or leaving Canada | $10,000 | CBSA: Travelling with CAN$10,000 or more Checked |
| Form T1135 reporting threshold Total cost amount of all specified foreign property at any time in the year, in Canadian dollars; filing is required when the total is more than this | $100,000 | Income Tax Act, s. 233.3(1) and (3) Checked |
| Normal individual income tax reassessment period After the earlier of the original assessment notice and original no-tax notification; exceptions apply. | Three years | Income Tax Act: section 152(3.1) Checked |
| Income-tax reassessment extension for specified foreign issues After the normal period for the specified non-resident transaction, foreign-affiliate amount, or T1135 plus unreported-income condition | Three years | Income Tax Act, subsection 152(4)(b) and (b.2) Checked |
| Reassessment time after an unreported sale of real estate is reported on an amended return Counted from the day the prescribed form amending the return to report the disposition is filed; until then no time limit applies to that disposition; limited to that disposition (s. 152(4.01)(c)) | Three years | Income Tax Act, s. 152(4)(b.3) and (4.01)(c) Checked |
| Income Tax Act false statement or omission penalty minimum The penalty is the greater of this amount and the percentage amount | $100 | Income Tax Act, section 163(2) Checked |
| Income Tax Act false statement or omission penalty rate Applied to the understated tax and certain related amounts, for a false statement or omission made knowingly or under circumstances amounting to gross negligence | 50% | Income Tax Act, section 163(2) Checked |
| Repeated failure to report income, minimum unreported amount Income Tax Act paragraphs 163(1)(a) and (b): the penalty applies when the unreported amount for the year, and an amount left out of any of the three preceding years' returns, are each at least this much, and subsection 163(2) does not apply to the unreported amount | $500 | Justice Laws: Income Tax Act, section 163 Checked |
| Repeated failure to report income, maximum penalty rate Income Tax Act paragraph 163(1.1)(a): the penalty is the lesser of this share of the unreported amount and half the amount by which the subsection 163(2) formula result exceeds tax withheld on the unreported amount | 10% | Justice Laws: Income Tax Act, section 163 Checked |
| CRA audit proposal response period Time to agree or disagree with a CRA audit proposal; check the letter's reply date | 30 days | CRA: What you should know about audits Checked |
Primary sources
- CRA: How does the CRA address non-compliance in the real estate sector?
- CRA: Income Tax Audit Manual, chapter 13, Audit techniques
- CRA: Business audits
- CRA: How we combat tax evasion and avoidance
- CRA: Responding to us
- CRA: Newcomers to Canada
- Income Tax Act, s. 128.1 (property owned on becoming a resident)
- Income Tax Act, s. 152 (assessments and reassessment periods)
- Income Tax Act, s. 163 (false statements and burden of proof)
- Income Tax Act, s. 231.1 (audits and questions)
- Income Tax Act, s. 231.2 (requirement to provide documents or information)
- Income Tax Act, s. 231.6 (foreign-based information)
- Income Tax Act, s. 239 (offences)
- CBSA: Travelling with CAN$10,000 or more
- Income Tax Act, s. 233.3 (foreign property return)
- Income Tax Act, s. 233.7 (no foreign property return for the year of first residence)
- Income Tax Act, s. 244.2 (electronic funds transfer reports)
About this guide
Edited and reviewed by Di Lu, CPA on . It explains general rules for the tax year shown. It is not advice for your situation.
Changes
- : First published.