Canada and the US · Individuals

Green card holder moving back to Canada: keep it or give it up

Canada taxes your world income from the day you set up residential ties, card or no card, unless the treaty tie-breaker places you in the US. The card decides whether the US also taxes world income. Surrender or a treaty claim ends that; count your card years first, because from an eighth year either can bring a US deemed sale.

Di Lu, CPA
Di Lu, CPAUS and Canadian CPA

Have a question about your situation?

Free · 15 minutes · Phone call

English & Chinese

Book a callChoose a time that works for youEmail: info@cloudacc.com

Tax year 2026 · Last updated  · Edited and reviewed by Di Lu, CPA

Who this is for

  • Canadians with a US green card who are moving back to Canada
  • Green card holders of any citizenship moving to Canada
  • People already living in Canada who still hold a green card

Not covered here

  • US citizens moving to Canada
  • Whether a green card can be kept while living in Canada (immigration law)
  • The exit tax calculation and Form 8854 line by line
  • US state tax in the move year

Moving back to Canada from the US with a green card: does Canada care if you keep it?

Generally no. Canada taxes your world income from the day you become resident there, with or without the card (CRA: newcomers' returns). The exception, a treaty tie-breaker that still places you in the US, is covered below. The card decides one thing: whether the US also keeps taxing your world income. A green card holder stays a US tax resident until the card is formally given up or taken away, or a treaty residence claim is made (IRS: residency ending dates; 26 U.S.C. 7701(b)(6)).

Your choiceWhat the US taxesWhat your Canadian return showsUS forms that continue
Keep the cardWorld income, as a US residentWorld income from your arrival date. Canada credits US tax only up to what the treaty lets the US charge a Canadian residentForm 1040 every year, the FBAR (the yearly report of non-US accounts), Form 8938 (a second foreign-asset report filed with the return), and the forms for Canadian plans and funds
Claim treaty residence in CanadaUS-source income, figured as a nonresidentThe same world income. Less US tax is paid, so the credit is smallerForm 1040-NR (the nonresident return) with Form 8833 (the treaty-claim disclosure) every year and the FBAR; Form 8854 (the statement filed when long-term residency ends) if you are a long-term resident
Surrender the cardWorld income through December 31 of the year the status ends (earlier in some cases), then US-source income onlyThe same world income. Less US tax is paid after the end date, so the credit is smallerA return for the year the status ends; Form 8854 if you are a long-term resident; later, Form 1040-NR only when US-source income calls for one

The Canadian column barely changes. The US columns do, and two of the choices are hard to undo: Form I-407 ends the status, and a first Form 1040-NR with Form 8833 can itself bring the US exit tax rules into play for a card held in at least 8 of the last 15 tax years.

A case is not simple when any of these is true:

  • the card has been held in seven or more tax years;
  • net worth is near US$2,000,000, or investments carry large unrealized gains;
  • a US return or foreign account report was missed in the last five years;
  • the day you become resident in Canada and the day the card ends are different days.

Gather the date the card was issued and any year you filed as a treaty nonresident, your last five US returns, the value of every asset on the day you arrived in Canada, a list of the plans and accounts you hold in each country, proof of the day you set up home in Canada (lease or purchase, moving dates, job start), your last five FBARs, and proof that Form I-407 was received if you filed it.

Whether a green card can be kept at all while you live in Canada is immigration law, not tax. An immigration lawyer answers that.

When does Canadian residency start, and when does US residency end?

Two different rules set the two dates, so they rarely fall on the same day. Canadian residency generally starts the day you enter Canada and set up residential ties. US residency under a green card runs until a formal event ends it.

Canada. The CRA looks at residential ties: a home, a spouse or common-law partner and dependants in Canada are the significant ones. A person who enters Canada and establishes those ties is generally resident from the date of entry (Folio S5-F1-C1, paragraphs 1.25 and 1.28). That date goes on your first Canadian return.

US. The table follows the IRS residency rules and Publication 519.

What happenedDoes US tax residency end?
You moved to CanadaNo
The card expired, or you have been away for yearsNo. You stay a resident until you have proof the card was given up, even if the card is more than 10 years old
You filed Form I-407, or a letter abandoning the status, with the cardYes. Keep proof it was received. For a long-term resident's expatriation date, the IRS also needs Homeland Security to confirm the abandonment (Publication 6164)
The US government revoked the status, or a final order found it abandonedYes, on the final order
You began to be treated as a resident of Canada under the treaty, kept the treaty's benefits and notified the IRSYes, for income tax (26 U.S.C. 7701(b)(6))

Even after one of these events, you generally stay a US resident through December 31 of that year. An earlier end date needs your tax home (your main place of work) and a closer connection outside the US for the rest of the year, among other conditions. Those conditions, expired cards, re-entry permits and the last resident day are covered in Green card holder living abroad.

What if the two dates overlap, or leave a gap?

An overlap is the normal case. From the day you become resident in Canada until the day the card ends, both countries tax your world income, and foreign tax credits or the treaty's tie-breaker settle which one gives way.

The CRA notes that the courts treat a green card holder as a US resident for the treaty's residence article (Folio S5-F1-C1, paragraph 1.44). A person in the overlap is therefore a resident of both countries, and Article IV(2) of the Canada–US treaty decides between them. It asks, in order: where you have a permanent home available; if in both or neither, where your personal and economic ties are closer; then where you usually live; then citizenship; and if you are a citizen of both or neither, the two tax authorities settle it by agreement. A home kept available to you in the US while you settle in Canada can send the question to the second test.

What you do with the answer changes both returns:

  • The tie-breaker points to Canada and you claim it on the US return. That is the treaty claim described further down. For a long-held card it is an expatriation event.
  • The tie-breaker points to Canada and you do not claim it. The US taxes you as a resident. The CRA treats US tax that the treaty does not let the US charge as a voluntary payment and gives no foreign tax credit for it (Folio S5-F2-C1, paragraph 1.34). The US return still credits Canadian tax against US tax on the same income, which usually covers Canadian-source pay and investment income (26 U.S.C. 901(b)(3); treaty Article XXIV(1)). What is left is US tax above what the treaty lets the US charge, mostly on US-source income; the treaty's special relief for that (Article XXIV(4) to (6)) is written for US citizens, not card holders. That leaves a choice between the US treaty claim, with the effects described further down, and paying that extra US tax.
  • The tie-breaker points to the US. Canada then treats you as a non-resident (paragraph 1.37 of the same residence folio), and the move date you planned is not your Canadian residency date.

A gap, a stretch when neither country treats you as a resident, is unusual, because leaving the US does not end US residency. It needs the card to end before your Canadian ties begin, such as a surrender followed by months of travel, and the US year-end rule above can still close it. The tests themselves are in Treaty tie-breaker for dual residents.

What cost does Canada give your US shares, funds and other property when you arrive?

Canada treats most property you own as sold and bought back at fair market value at the moment you become resident. That value, in Canadian dollars, is your cost for Canadian tax from then on, so Canada measures gain or loss only from the arrival date (Income Tax Act, section 128.1(1)(b) and (c)).

Two groups are left out. Taxable Canadian property, which includes real estate in Canada, keeps its original cost. Rights under pension and retirement plans, Canadian registered plans such as an RRSP, TFSA or RESP, and employee stock options are not revalued either.

The CRA tells people arriving in Canada to keep a record of each property's fair market value on the arrival date, because that value is the cost used for a later sale (CRA). Dated account statements do this for listed shares and funds. Real estate and private company shares are better supported by a written valuation.

Those values also count for Form T1135, Canada's foreign property report, due for any year the total cost of your property outside Canada is more than C$100,000 at any time (s. 233.3). Only someone who first becomes resident in Canada that year is exempt (s. 233.7), so a Canadian moving back usually files one for the move year.

While you keep the card, your US cost does not change: the US still measures gain from what you paid (Publication 551). One later sale then shows two different gains, one on each return, in two currencies.

If you owned the property when you last left Canada, an election for returning residents can change the result: see Returning to Canada after years abroad.

Giving up a green card and the exit tax: does the US deemed sale match Canada's arrival value?

Only some people have a US deemed sale. It applies to a long-term resident, meaning someone who held the card in at least 8 of the last 15 tax years, who is also a covered expatriate. That person's property is treated as sold at fair market value on the day before the expatriation date (26 U.S.C. 877A; Form 8854 instructions). For a treaty claim, the expatriation date is the day treaty residence in Canada began, not the day the return is filed.

A long-term resident is a covered expatriate if net worth is US$2,000,000 or more, if average annual US income tax for the five years before is more than US$211,000, or if five years of US tax compliance cannot be certified on Form 8854. Up to US$910,000 of deemed gain is excluded. Property you owned before you first became a US resident can start from a higher US cost for the deemed sale. The tests and the calculation are in US exit tax.

Retirement plans and deferred pay, Canadian plans included, are not part of the deemed sale. A covered expatriate's IRA is treated as fully paid out the day before the expatriation date; other plans face 30% withholding on later payments or are taxed at their present value (26 U.S.C. 877A(c) to (e)). The table below covers investments only; for the plans see US exit tax and US retirement accounts in Canada.

Whether the same gain is taxed twice depends on the order of two dates.

Order of the datesUS deemed sale usesCanada's cost isResult
The card ends on or before the day you become resident in CanadaThe value the day before the card endsThe value on arrivalThe same or nearly the same value when the dates are close. Canada starts from where the US stopped
You become resident in Canada first, and the card ends laterThe value the day before the card endsThe value on arrival, an earlier dateThe growth between the two dates is inside the US deemed sale and above Canada's cost, so Canada counts it again when you sell
You claim treaty residence in Canada from the day you become resident thereThe value the day before treaty residence beganThe value on arrivalAbout the same value
You are not a long-term resident, or not a covered expatriateNo deemed saleThe value on arrivalNothing to line up. A long-term resident still files Form 8854

For the second row, Article XIII(7) of the treaty lets an individual who is treated by one country as having disposed of a property, and is taxed there because of it, elect to be treated in the other country as having sold and bought back the property at fair market value immediately before that time. Read on its terms, an election made in Canada would put the in-between gain on the Canadian return for the year of the US deemed sale and raise the Canadian cost to that value. The treaty and its technical explanation do not work through the case of a green card holder already resident in Canada. The explanation does say the election covers all the property deemed sold that year, not a chosen few, and applies only when those deemed sales give a net gain.

Whether the election lowers the total, and which country gives credit for the other's tax on that gain, depends on where the treaty places your residence on those dates. Work it through on both returns before filing either.

Cross-border tax

Moving back to Canada with a green card?

Call if the card is near its eighth year, your Canadian arrival date and the card's end date differ, or a US return or account report was missed. We prepare the US and Canadian returns for the move year together, with Form 8854 where it is due. The first call covers your dates and what you hold in each country, and sets the scope.

  • The card's issue date, your last five US returns and FBARs.
  • The day you set up home in Canada, and each asset's value that day.

Free · 15 minutes

Plan your move year

Cross-border tax

In what order should you do things in the move year?

Count first, then fix the date, then decide the card. The order matters because the count and the date cannot be changed afterward.

  1. Count your card years. Count tax years, not anniversaries: a year can count even if you held the card for only part of it. Leave out a year in which you were treated as a resident of another country under a treaty and did not waive its benefits (Form 8854 instructions).
  2. Fix your Canadian residency date. Keep the evidence: the lease or purchase, the day your household moved, the day work started.
  3. Value every asset on that date. Record each value in both currencies, with the exchange rate used.
  4. Test for covered expatriate status if your count is eight or will reach eight: net worth, five years of US tax, five years of filings. If a US return is missing, see Behind on US and Canadian tax returns before you act.
  5. If this is your seventh card year, decide before January 1. Holding the card on any day of the next year makes it an eighth year, which makes you a long-term resident.
  6. End the status the way you chose. File Form I-407 with the card and keep proof of receipt, or make the treaty claim on Form 1040-NR with Form 8833. Either one can end your right to live in the US: take immigration advice first.
  7. File the returns. Canada: a return showing your date of entry and world income from that date. US: a dual-status return (resident for part of the year, nonresident for the rest) only if your US residency ended before December 31 under the rule above; otherwise a full-year resident return (IRS: dual-status individuals). A long-term resident attaches Form 8854 to the return for the year that includes the expatriation date; a missing or incomplete form can cost US$10,000.

Both countries' move-year returns are laid out in Moving from the US to Canada, and the US departure-year return in Leaving the US.

Maintaining a US green card while living in Canada: what do a TFSA, FHSA, RESP, RRSP or Canadian fund cost on the US side?

While you keep the card you are a US resident who lives in Canada. The US return reports world income, the FBAR is due when your accounts outside the US together go over US$10,000, and Form 8938 may apply. A plan's tax break in Canada carries over to the US return only where the treaty says so.

Plan or holdingOn the US return while the card is keptGuide
RRSP or RRIFIncome inside is deferred until withdrawn for eligible individuals (Rev. Proc. 2014-55); still reported on the FBAR and Form 8938Canadian registered accounts on a US return
TFSANo treaty deferral: income is taxable, with no Canadian tax to credit; Canadian funds inside follow the fund rules below; reportable on the FBAR (IRS FBAR guide)TFSA and FHSA holdings
FHSANo treaty deferral, and no IRS guidance on how it is taxedTFSA and FHSA holdings
RESPA non-binding IRS letter says the treaty does not defer its income; foreign trust forms may applyRESP and US tax
Canadian corporation you ownForm 5471 each year, and some of its income can be taxed on your US return before any dividend is paid (Form 5471 instructions)American owners of Canadian corporations
Canadian mutual fund or ETFCan be a passive foreign investment company, with its own Form 8621 (instructions)Form 8621 filing and missed years

Some of the linked guides are written for US citizens. A green card holder who is still a US tax resident is taxed on these plans the same way.

Claiming treaty residence in Canada instead of surrendering: what changes on the Canadian return?

Nothing changes in your Canadian residence: you report world income from your arrival date either way. What changes is the US tax there is to credit. Under the claim the US figures your income tax as a nonresident, on Form 1040-NR with Form 8833 attached (Publication 519), so the Canadian foreign tax credit covers only US tax on US-source income at the treaty's limits. Tax withheld above a treaty rate is not creditable in Canada; the CRA expects you to claim it back from the US (Folio S5-F2-C1, paragraph 1.35).

Three things come with the claim:

  • It is made on each year's return. A position that is not disclosed on Form 8833 costs US$1,000 (Form 8833).
  • For a long-term resident it is the expatriation event. Form 8833 itself says a long-term resident who makes the claim is treated as having ended US residency, must file Form 8854, and may face the deemed sale above.
  • It can affect the card. The Treasury regulation says filing Form 1040-NR this way may affect the immigration authorities' decision on whether you keep a residency permit (26 CFR 301.7701(b)-7(b)). That question belongs to an immigration lawyer.

You remain a US resident for purposes other than figuring income tax. The FBAR is still due, because treaties do not change FBAR filing (IRS FBAR guide). Form 8938 is not required for the period covered by a timely Form 1040-NR with Form 8833 (Form 8938 instructions). The claim and the form are covered in Treaty tie-breaker for dual residents.

After you give up the green card: how is your remaining US income taxed in each country?

After the status ends, the US taxes you as a nonresident, on US-source income and income connected with a US business (Publication 519). Canada taxes your world income and gives a foreign tax credit for the US tax the treaty allows.

Pay for work done in the US is generally taxed there first and credited in Canada. US dividends face withholding of up to 15% under the treaty instead of the standard 30%, and periodic pension payments up to 15%, once you give each US payer Form W-8BEN in place of the Form W-9 it holds (Form W-8BEN instructions). For ten years after the status ends, the treaty lets the US tax a former long-term resident's US-source income under its own law (Article XXIX(2)(b), technical explanation), so these treaty rates may not apply to one. US social security paid to a resident of Canada is taxable only in Canada (treaty, Article XVIII(5)). Rent from a US home you keep is subject to 30% withholding on the gross unless you choose to be taxed on net rent (Publication 519); see Canadians with US rental property. Covered expatriates face separate withholding on some retirement payments; see US exit tax. For a 401(k) or IRA see US retirement accounts in Canada; for the last resident day and the last FBAR year see Green card holder living abroad.

Example

Illustrative only, with round numbers. Amounts are in US dollars unless marked C$.

Seven card years: surrender in the move year

Priya, a Canadian citizen, got her green card in 2020. She moves from Seattle to Toronto on July 1, 2026. Her US brokerage account is worth US$400,000 that day against a cost of US$250,000.

  • 2020 to 2026: seven tax years with the card.
  • July 1, 2026: Canadian residency starts. Canada's cost for the account is the July 1 value, converted to Canadian dollars at that day's rate.
  • September 2026: she files Form I-407 with the card. With seven years she is not a long-term resident: no Form 8854 and no US deemed sale. July to September is an overlap in which both countries tax her world income. If her tax home and closer connection are in Canada for the rest of the year and she is not a US resident in 2027, her US residency ends that day and her US return for 2026 is a dual-status return.
  • If she waits until January 2027: 2027 is an eighth tax year. She is now a long-term resident, must file Form 8854, and has a deemed sale unless she falls outside all three covered expatriate tests. If one applies, the US deemed sale uses the January 2027 value while Canada's cost stays at the July 1, 2026 value.

Long-held card: Canadian residency first, surrender later

Marc has held his card since 2014 and has a net worth of US$2,500,000, so he is a long-term resident and a covered expatriate. He moves to Vancouver on March 1, 2026 and surrenders the card on November 1, 2026. His shares, bought after he became a US resident, cost US$100,000 and are worth US$1,000,000 on March 1 and US$1,200,000 on October 31.

  • Canada: cost is the March 1 value, US$1,000,000, converted to Canadian dollars at that day's rate.
  • US: the deemed sale uses the October 31 value. Deemed gain is US$1,100,000 before the exclusion.
  • The overlap: the US$200,000 of growth from March to October is inside the US deemed sale and also above Canada's cost. Without the Article XIII(7) election Canada taxes it again in the year he really sells. With the election, read on its terms, Canada would tax it for 2026 and his Canadian cost would rise to the October 31 value. Had the tie-breaker placed him in Canada from March 1 and he claimed it, his expatriation date would be March 1 and the deemed sale would use the February 28 value. Which result costs less needs both returns worked through.

Keeping the card: a TFSA

Wei, born in Hong Kong and a Canadian citizen, keeps her card after moving to Calgary because her employer may send her back. She has C$20,000 of unused TFSA room from her years in Canada before the move (room builds only for years you are resident in Canada, s. 207.01) and puts it in Canadian mutual funds.

  • Canada: income earned inside the TFSA is generally tax-free (CRA).
  • US: her Form 1040 reports what the funds pay out and any gain when she sells, taxed under the fund rules (with an interest charge unless she makes an election), with no Canadian tax to credit. Each fund may need a Form 8621 unless a small-holding exception applies, and the TFSA goes on her FBAR with her other Canadian accounts.
  • Immigration: whether her card survives living in Calgary is a question for an immigration lawyer, not a tax question.

Different for you?

Figures on this page

FigureValueSource
Green card history that makes a lawful permanent resident a long-term resident
A dual-resident long-term resident who claims treaty nonresidence on Form 8833 is deemed to terminate US residency (section 877A; Form 8854).
At least 8 of the last 15 tax yearsIRS: Form 8833 instructions, Termination of U.S. Residency
Checked
Net worth test
Covered expatriate if net worth on the expatriation date is this amount or more
US$2,000,000IRS: Instructions for Form 8854
Checked
Form T1135 reporting threshold
Total cost amount of all specified foreign property at any time in the year, in Canadian dollars; filing is required when the total is more than this
C$100,000Income Tax Act, s. 233.3(1) and (3)
Checked
Average annual net income tax test
Covered expatriate if the average for the five preceding tax years is more than this amount
US$211,000
Tax year 2026
IRS: Revenue Procedure 2025-32, section 4.37
Checked
Exit tax deemed-gain exclusion
Reduction of gain otherwise included under the mark-to-market rule, but not below zero
US$910,000
Tax year 2026
IRS: Revenue Procedure 2025-32, section 4.38
Checked
Eligible deferred compensation withholding
Withholding on taxable payments to a covered expatriate from an eligible deferred compensation item
30%Internal Revenue Code section 877A(d)(1)
Checked
Form 8854 failure penalty
Per required year for a missing, incomplete, or incorrect form, unless reasonable cause applies
US$10,000IRS: Instructions for Form 8854
Checked
FBAR filing threshold
Total maximum value of all foreign financial accounts at any time in the calendar year; an FBAR is required when the total is more than this
US$10,000FinCEN: Report Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts
Checked
Penalty for not disclosing a treaty-based return position
Per failure, under section 6712; applies to taxpayers other than C corporations.
US$1,000IRS: Form 8833 (Rev. December 2022)
Checked
Canada–US treaty dividend withholding rate, all other cases
Article X(2)(b): rate on dividends when the beneficial owner is not a company holding at least 10% of the voting stock, including an individual
15%Department of Finance Canada: Canada–United States Tax Convention (consolidated)
Checked
Withholding rate on US-source FDAP income paid to foreign persons
Applies to the gross amount of US-source FDAP income not effectively connected with a US trade or business; a treaty may lower it. Also the rate on pay to non-resident independent contractors for services performed in the US.
30%IRS: Fixed, determinable, annual, or periodical (FDAP) income
Checked
Canada–US treaty cap on source-country tax for periodic pension payments
Article XVIII(2)(a): qualifying periodic pension payment to a beneficial owner resident in the other country, as a share of the gross payment.
15%Department of Finance Canada: Canada–United States tax convention, Article XVIII(2)(a)
Checked

Primary sources

About this guide

Edited and reviewed by Di Lu, CPA on . It explains general rules for the tax year shown. It is not advice for your situation.

Changes

  • : First published.
Di Lu, CPA
Di Lu, CPAUS and Canadian CPA

Ready to talk through your next step?

Free · 15 minutes · Phone call

English & Chinese

A first call to discuss your needs and how we can help.

Book a callChoose a time that works for youEmail: info@cloudacc.com

Book a consultation

Free · 15 minutes

By booking, you agree to our privacy policy. If an ad brought you here, we tell that ad platform when you book, and may tell it when you spend time on a page, tap our phone number or pick a time. We never share your name, email or phone. Privacy policy

Calendar not loading? Book a consultation